Where to play Magic: The Gathering in New York

235 stores in 134 cities across New York. Cities with the most: Brooklyn, New York, Buffalo.

Albany Altamount Amherst Amsterdam Attica Baldwin Baldwinsville Batavia Beacon Binghamton Bronx Brookhaven Brooklyn Buffalo Canandaigua Candor Canton Castleton-on-Hudson Catskill Center Moriches Cheektowaga Chester Clay Clifton Park Clifton Springs Clinton Cobleskill Corning Cortland Cortlandt Manor Deer Park Depew East Amherst East Greenbush Elbridge Ellenville Elmhurst Elmira Heights Elmont Esopus Florida Flushing Forest Hills Fort Drum Fort Edward Fredonia Fulton Geneva Glenmont Glens Falls Greenville Harriman Herkimer Holland Patent Hornell Horseheads Huntington Hyde Park Irvington Ithaca Jamestown Kingston Lake Ronkonkoma Larchmont Le Roy Levittown Lindenhurst Lockport Long Island City Manlius Massapequa Massena Medford Menands Middle Village Middletown Montgomery Mount Morris Nanuet New City New Hartford New Hyde Park New Paltz New Windsor New York Newburgh North Tonawanda Norwich Oakdale Ogdensburg Olean Oneonta Oswego Otego Owego Patchogue Pine Bush Plattsburgh Port Jervis Potsdam Poughkeepsie Pulaski Queens Queensbury Rochester Rocky Point Rome Ronkonkoma Salina Saratoga Springs Scarsdale Schenectady Scotia Selden Seneca Falls Shirley Smithtown Staten Island Syracuse Tonawanda Troy Valley Stream Vestal Walton Wantagh Waterloo Watertown Webster West Babylon Westbury Whitehall Whitesboro Williamsville Yonkers

Showing the 24 most-reviewed stores out of 235. Use the links above to browse all of them by city.

Best Buy - Henrietta

2345 Marketplace Dr, Rochester

4.1(4346)

Magic: The Gathering

Millennium Games

1225 W Jefferson Rd a17, Rochester, NY 14692, USA, Rochester

4.7(2920)

Disney LorcanaYu-Gi-Oh!Magic: The GatheringDigimon Card GameDragon Ball Super Card GameGundam Card GameRiftboundFinal Fantasy TCGOne Piece Card GameFlesh and Blood

Alamo Drafthouse Lower Manhattan

28 Liberty St Suite SC301, New York

4.4(1692)

Magic: The Gathering

The Compleat Strategist

11 East 33rd Street, New York

4.6(1248)

Disney LorcanaMagic: The GatheringStar Wars: UnlimitedRiftbound

GameStop - 6562 - New York

32 E 14th St, New York

3.8(1218)

Magic: The Gathering

FASTBREAK X INCEPTION TCG

3720 Prince St Ste 1C , Flushing

4.9(1159)

Magic: The GatheringDragon Ball Super Card GameGundam Card GameRiftboundOne Piece Card Game

Peculier Pub

145 Bleecker St, New York

4.4(1123)

Magic: The Gathering

Hex and Company

2911 Broadway, New York

4.7(889)

Magic: The Gathering

GameStop - 4618 - Queens Center Adjacent

90-15 Queens Blvd, Elmhurst

3.9(850)

Magic: The Gathering

Twenty Sided

280 Grand St, Brooklyn

4.9(707)

Magic: The GatheringStar Wars: Unlimited

ToyWiz

347 W. Route 59, Nanuet

3.9(687)

Disney LorcanaCyberpunk TCGMagic: The GatheringDigimon Card GameDragon Ball Super Card GameStar Wars: UnlimitedPokémon TCGGundam Card GameRiftboundFinal Fantasy TCGOne Piece Card Game

Just Games

1601 Penfield Rd Unit 34, Rochester

4.9(664)

Disney LorcanaMagic: The GatheringDigimon Card GameStar Wars: UnlimitedPokémon TCGRiftbound

Larger Than Life Toys & Comics

4100 NY-31, Clay, NY 13041, USA, Clay

4.4(630)

Disney LorcanaMagic: The GatheringFinal Fantasy TCGFlesh and Blood

OS NYC

50 Bowery, New York, NY 10013, USA, New York

4.6(590)

Magic: The GatheringRiftbound

Brothers Grim Games

1244 Middle Country Road, Selden

4.3(587)

Disney LorcanaYu-Gi-Oh!Magic: The GatheringDigimon Card GameDragon Ball Super Card GameStar Wars: UnlimitedGundam Card GameRiftboundFinal Fantasy TCGOne Piece Card Game

Bulletproof Comics and Games

2178 Nostrand Avenue, Brooklyn

4.7(572)

Yu-Gi-Oh!Magic: The Gathering

Sip & Play Boardgame Cafe

471 5th Avenue, Brooklyn

4.6(558)

Disney LorcanaMagic: The GatheringRiftbound

GameStop - 6623 - Carousel Center Mall

9598 Destiny USA Dr, Syracuse

4.1(556)

Magic: The Gathering

Next Move Cafe

2059 86th Street, 3rd Floor, Brooklyn

5.0(542)

Magic: The GatheringRiftbound

GameStop - 2850 - Atlantic Terminal

139 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn

3.9(475)

Magic: The Gathering

Casual Dragon Games Amherst

3908 Maple Rd, Buffalo, NY 14226, USA, Buffalo

4.7(468)

Yu-Gi-Oh!Magic: The GatheringStar Wars: UnlimitedGundam Card GameRiftboundOne Piece Card GameFlesh and Blood

Great Escape Adventures - Horseheads

3300 Chambers Road, Horseheads

4.5(467)

Disney LorcanaMagic: The GatheringRiftbound

GameStop - 2324 - Parkchester CBD

1449 Metropolitan Ave, Bronx

3.8(427)

Magic: The Gathering

Hex and Company East

1462 Broadway, New York

4.4(419)

Disney LorcanaMagic: The GatheringGundam Card GameRiftboundOne Piece Card Game