Casual Dragon Games Amherst

Just went there to trade some cards and was offered 50% credit and 30% cash on TCGplayer market which is by far the worst rate I’ve ever heard for a local card shop. Called them on the phone to make sure they even took trades and they didn’t mention the rate until I got to the shop either.

If I could give 10 stars, I would!! I have been coming here for a while now and I have only ever had the most wonderful experiences with the staff and I have met many great people with which to play Magic! I would absolutely highly recommend!! And I’ve never had any issues with judges calls 🙌

The staff here is incredible. The best energy at any game store I've tried in the area, and I've tried quite a few. There's always someone ready to help if you need it, and their professional but playful energy keeps bringing me back. Beyond that, their stock is always neat and clean, and almost always at or below msrp. Then, there's the company. I've made better connections with other players here than I ever have at any other lgs - in Buffalo or beyond. Casual Dragon is worth your time 👌🏼

Their Magic: The Gathering bulk collection is insane, bins full (pictured below). Everything in there costs either a quarter or a dime, so much cheaper than anywhere else I’ve found. Staff are very friendly and helpful too! It’s clean, welcoming, and I couldn’t recommend it more.

As one of the best local gaming stores in the area, I feel lucky to have it so close. They have card games (from Fluxx to MtG), board games, dice games, RPGs and minis. They do have some demo games in the back, and some table space so folks can try out a game before buying it. They also do painting days and gaming days. The new location is a little easier to navigate than the old store on the Millersport too.