Toy Tyme Collectibles & TCG

Very impressed with the shop! My 8 year old son and 6 year old daughter have just started being interested in Pokémon cards and this is a great shop to start to build their collections. The employees were super helpful and answered so many of my kids questions with great enthusiasm! I’d give this place 10 stars if possible.

I had a pretty subpar experience here. This shop was recommended to me by a friend, so I made a long drive to try and trade some cards in to buy sealed product for a loved one's birthday. First, the employee mistakenly comped my two most expensive cards at around 20% of their true value. Whatever, mistakes happen, no biggie. But then the employee kept trying to defend the valuation until I pulled out TCGplayer and showed what the value of the cards should be. After finally agreeing on a market value, I was offered a little more than 50% trade value towards a product that is already 3x MSRP. Being a local card shop, I was expecting a better deal and walked out of there with regret knowing I could've gotten my purchase cheaper from scalpers on Facebook. The employees were friendly but tried to squeeze me for every dollar I had. I will not be returning.

One of the best card shops I have ever been too!! The staff is very helpful and knowledgeable! They have super fair prices and offer a wide selection of products! Have done buisness with them on multiple random occasions and I can now say I am a regular! There's no other card shop in the area I would rather go to! Also very polite and helpful to the whole community and always looking out for the kiddos! Great job guys keep up the good work!! Always a pleasure doing buisness!

Toy Tyme Collectibles & TCG in New Lenox is easily one of the best card shops in the area. They consistently offer competitive pricing, making it a great place for both collectors and players alike. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely helpful, creating a welcoming atmosphere for anyone who walks through the door. What really stands out is their honesty and fairness—they take the time to ensure customers feel confident in their purchases and trades. The store also maintains an excellent selection of singles and sealed products, catering to a wide range of interests. If you’re in the area and looking for a reliable, well-run card shop, Toy Tyme Collectibles & TCG is definitely worth a visit.

Fantastic place to grab pretty much any TCG you can think of. They hold weekly play nights and host organized play tournaments often. The people working here are doing things right and bringing something special to the community.