Secret Door Games

Awesome place to go to get away from reality and just hang n chill. People are real cool and genuine. Highly recommend visiting, you'll wanna leave with something too. Feel like a kid again. Ask for Aaron, he's like a dictionary/library for any questions or just chat.

Players: Great gaggle of folk! Happy I got the chance to play some games and get to know them. Staff: The short and stout Hispanic guy must've been having an off night. He was rude and treated me like a fart in the wind when I had questions. The more seasoned Caucasian male was very pleasant and made up for the other guy's blow off attitude (give that man a raise). Atmosphere: Fantastic! Really homey play area and the shop front had that tavern vibe you hunt for for RPGs. Selection: Singles are well sorted and their inventory is above par in my experience. I've been to and played at dozens of LGSs in the state of IN. This shop was above the average experience, but that staff member that was rude kind of got to me... I've been to dive LGSs that make up for any fault just by offering a courteous service and reasonable accommodations.

Great location. Staff is fantastic. Everyone there was very welcoming and social. Selection is fantastic. Amazing place to play and shop!

Went to purchase cards, my son and I play as well as collect. We were being charged median mint prices on played and we'll played cards. We were given reasons, such as they pay a higher trade in value.... I was there to purchase, not trade, the price you pay for your inventory is not my concern, but being charged a reasonable market value is. My selection was 3-7 dollar market value cards, my total was $32. I did not pay the additional $4 per card, I ordered from tcgplayer while standing at the registered and waited the 3 days for shipping.... oh and I got them in mint foil, instead of well played regular, for $23 INCLUDING SHIPPING. My son's selection was a 63 dollar card, and his total came to 89. Again, was ordered on tcg and arrived days later. We hope the store does well but we won't be back, too much is spent in cards to pay a premium for defects.

Will is a great host and manager period I had a lot of fun here and there is a lot of things the store has to offer right in downtown Elkhart, Indiana. There's a really good group of Magic players and very diverse age group and skill level. The players here are very friendly with helping people get the ropes of how to draft a deck. There is a lot of energy at this shop and it is a must see! Definitely won't be a boring experience. I highly recommend come. Check this place out!