Misty Mountain Games

Great selection of cards, and some awesome prices! One of the cheapest places I know of for certain card sleeves (I'll pretty much only buy here now). I also love how easy it is to sell cards here. Nice to see on their website what they will give me before I make a decision (and they have reasonable returns for them) I love how their MTG boosters are organized. Kind of a neat display, a lot more organized than a lot of stores I've been to. Overall one of my favorite places to buy cards online. Great selection, and great staff at the store!

Overall I have liked all the employees and they keep up as best as they can with keeping Pokemon inventory. But then today happened and I’m on fire. I was buying booster bundles of chaos rising and they had 4 Left. Bought first one, nothing, went to buy second one and employee 1 grabbed it for me and employee 2 smacked the box out of his hand and grabbed a different one. I Didn’t care at the time cause I was buying all 4 If I didnt get anything. There were not anyone but employees in. The store cause it was closing time. Then employees 1 decided to buy the box that he had for me mid shift and open it. I came back in from opening nothing once again just to face employee 1 rubbing the $500 greninja in my face. The box I would have been buying and opening next. I’m so fired up cause one, it’s unprofessional to buy during working hours. Two. It’s card ripping ethic-it to not jump in all of a sudden and buy a box when someone’s going on a run. Especially an employee. Won’t be buying anything from this place ever again. Now the place just had bad juju

I placed an order with Misty Mountain Games on the 20th worth over $4,000. A full week went by with zero communication, so I called the store on the 27th to follow up. They told me they would email shortly to finalise the order — and the email I received was extremely disappointing. They informed me that multiple cards were missing, several others were in the wrong condition, and their inventory was not accurate. On top of that, they claimed the order had “pricing discrepancies,” even though they are the ones who set the prices. Then, instead of fixing the issues or honouring the order, they simply cancelled everything and refunded me the next day. For a store of this size, having an out‑of‑date inventory, incorrect card conditions, and then blaming the customer for “pricing issues” is unacceptable. I wasted over a week waiting for an order they clearly never had the ability to fulfil. I won’t be ordering from them again.

Great local spot for playing TCGs and other tabletop games. I routinely come to play Riftbound TCG and the events are very well run. They offer store credit per win at weekly locals and larger prizing for bigger tournaments. I have also sold bulk cards here and the process is quick and easy. They can send you an itemized breakdown upon request and offer 10% more if you choose store credit. The shop is very clean and well organized. There's a nice selection of singles and sealed, which are both at market price. You do get a discount if you buy 3+ booster packs in a single purchase, though. Shout out to the friendly staff!

Truly the greatest LCG in Madison. Any time a need to buy a gift for one of my kid’s friends, the staff is really helpful if picking out something perfect. They are incredibly fast at fulfilling MTG single orders, and great with suggestions on deck building.