Game Time

I love Game Time!!! I drive almost an hour to come here and I've only had good experiences. This store is super useful for building MTG decks since you can give them a list of singles and they'll find everything instead of trying to sift through thousands of bulk cards. Their prices are also super reasonable, most cards are priced at market value and packs of cards are at MSRP (which is pretty standard, but still commendable in my opinion in a world so desperate to profit). In addition to the store itself, the employees are very kind and helpful and the other customers are too! Multiple times now I have had people jump in to pick out cards I'm looking for while they look for themselves which is so wonderful. See you next paycheck ;)

Nice store, very clean, impressive selection. Staff was very friendly and very helpful! Even took the time to find a specific card that I haven't been able to find in months! Definitely made my day stopping in and will absolutely stop by next time in the area (live about 3 hours away).

These guys stink man. Their prices are awful and their buy offers are actually offensive, we’re talking 50% or below market on even new stuff. Take a hike up north in Noblesville to Moonshot, their prices can stink too but the selection is CRAZY GOOD, and they are WAY WAY BETTER with offers. I don’t know how these guys stay in business with Microcenter around the corner honestly, it’s a ripoff hub. How you gonna quote market plus for singles but offer less than half? Haha

I was offered 60% of my card's worth. I'm relatively new to collecting cards, and the guy that explained the price into me seemed annoyed that he even had to explain it to me. Gave me what seemed like a fair price on the bulk of my cards. But whenever it came to a fairly expensive card that I had. I was offered 60% of its worth. Good place to pick up stuff doesn't seem like a good place to sell

I hear a lot of people mention bad experiences here, but I've never had a bad experience...! The employees will check everything you ask about, talk to you, and help you find what you need. I gladly utilize this store for shopping - and they frequently have MTG cards that other stores don't have in stock! Thanks for reading my review. Have a great day!