Board Game Barrister - Mayfair

Absolutely amazing workers. I was assisted constantly and Wyatt was so respectful and kind. My items were held for me while I continued shopping and there was a lot of recommendations based on my likings! Recommend this place for a visit! :)

Wyatt helped me out at this location! It was perfect. Great game recommendations which were matching the details I gave as well as being hospitable!! I would definitely recommend :)

I live in Alaska but have a home in southeast Wisconsin. I discovered Board Game Barrister in the Autumn of 2025 while visiting then and have been back several times. Each time, the staff was friendly and helpful. Yesterday's experience was particularly nice with conversations with both Wyatt and Riley. When I move back to southeast Wisconsin in retirement, I anticipate making regular visits to Board Game Barrister for additional games and accessories!

One-stop shop. A gamer's paradise! Huge store filled to the brim, no supply shortage here! Old-fashioned games. Strategy games. Party games. Toddler games. Puzzles. 3D puzzles. Card games. Chess. Pokémon. Solo games. Games I've never heard of. Games I could never imagine existed! Get the point....they have everything! Prices are a consistent $10 higher than Amazon. I was price-matching as I shopped. However, I paid the extra cost happily for a few reasons. 1. The unheard-of selection blew me away! 2. The customer service was incredible. One gentleman walked with me through the entire process helping me find the perfect gifts and games! He knew every game and was quick and proficient to answer every question. 3. I NEVER want to see this store fail. I will happily pay a little more for the staff's knowledge and the on-hand selection. 4. My Amazon Games would not have gotten to me by Christmas. 5. I was too impatient to wait for an Amazon delivery because I was so jacked to play the games that very night! Go today.....seriously go. You won't regret it! We spent so many hours together as a family playing these games! Thank you! They also have a great reward program that I will be using frequently! I believe the gentleman that assisted me was named Phill and Wendal. Thanks to you both!

They have a really large selection of board games, kids games, puzzles, etc. I really liked how the sections were organized. The store had plenty of room to move around in and even had a few games set up to try. If your near by and like games I'd wouldn't miss it. They even have a clearance and used section.