Smitty's Cards and Coins

Great little card and coin store in the downtown area that was a perfect way to spend some time looking at Magic cards both old and new. Decent selection of singles and playsets of cards and very friendly staff willing to chat about the game and what cards you might be looking for. Great experience during my trip to Canandaigua!

Nothing but amazing things to say about Smitty’s and the crew that works there. Helpful, great prices, fair trades, always have a great experience when I stop in. Super family friendly, my 6 year old gets excited every time we go. Easily the best card shop in the entire Fingerlakes/Rochester area

Great experience. Prices are very fair and staff are friendly. My dad and I bought on whatnot and decided to see the shop in person. I asked to have a coin checked I bought elsewhere for authenticity and they were very accommodating. Picked up a few items as well. Will be back!

This shop is both honest and professional. It gives you the small town feel when you walk in. Everyone there takes great pride in how they treat their customers. The owner, is extremely knowledgeable and honest. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking to add to their collection or make transactions.

I've been collecting coins and silver for a little over a year now and Smittys is a great small coin shop that also sells, buys and trades magic the gathering and other cards.(I'm not too knowledgeable about these card games. I went to check out coins and Silver.) I felt very comfortable there with the helpful staff and the no pressure way they do business there. They have a large selection of junk / constitutional (90% and 40%) Silver coins, gold bullion coins, proof sets, collecting supplies and so much more. They also usually have some nice silver and gold bullion. The staff is the nicest I've found at a local coin shop so far. Easy to talk to and very knowledgeable about all things coin and game card related. Definitely NOT a high pressure sales place like I've been to before. I'd highly recommend checking Smittys out for the beginner as well as seasoned veteran collectors.