Overtime Cards and Collectibles

Went for two pre rift events for Riftbound and had a blast! Mich is so chill and the event was fun and chill. Will def be back

Sold us a $7 card for $25. Their mark ups are shameless. We went in with good faith and they took advantage of it. They clearly prioritize making a quick buck over gaining the confidence of their customers. Do not recommend.

Friendly staff, great selection of cards! Was helped by very nice and knowledgeable people on my first NHL card purchases, and the free sleeves made me feel reassured that my valuable pulls were protected. Clean shop with great atmosphere. Will come again.

Overtime cards is by far the best LCS that I have been lucky enough to come across. When I moved to Utah a few years back, I wasn’t sure if I would be able to find an Lcs that I would frequent. There are a few in the area but Overtime is by far the best. They have a great selection of singles, sealed and have a great PSA grading service. The staff is great and they put on great events for the community. Highly recommend the shop!

I walked in knowing absolutely nothing about baseball cards, just a mom on a mission to find a gift for my 13-year-old son. I was told the owner was the person to talk to, so I felt like I was in good hands. I explained exactly who I was shopping for and asked for a recommendation. He pointed me toward a "Stars and Stripes" box, speaking highly of it. I trusted his expertise and bought a full box as a gift, plus a single pack for my younger son who was shopping with me to open for fun. When we opened that single pack, here's what we got: a 12U player, a 14U player, a 15U player, an 18U player, and a college athlete. Not a single MLB player. Not one professional. Just a collection of kids and college prospects my son has never heard of and has no connection to. Turns out the entire Stars and Stripes product is college athletes and youth tournament players. Which is fine, but it is absolutely not a gift a 13-year-old baseball fan is going to get excited about. I came in trusting a specialist to steer me right, and instead I got a recommendation that felt more like moving product than actually helping a customer. I felt completely duped, and honestly too uncomfortable to go back in myself. So I sent my husband to ask about exchanging the unopened box for something more appropriate, a reasonable request given I had made the purchase less than 24 hours earlier. The owner's response was flat-out rude. No explanation, no empathy, just no. It took my husband continuing to calmly press the issue before the owner finally relented and allowed the exchange. No apology. No acknowledgment that the original recommendation missed the mark entirely. Just reluctant cooperation after making the whole experience as unpleasant as possible. I came in trusting a specialist to steer me right and left feeling taken advantage of. If you're a knowledgeable collector, maybe this shop works for you. But if you're a parent walking in cold, do your research before you buy, because the guidance here clearly isn't looking out for you.