Ohio Card Exchange

My wife went into sell some excellent cards while I was sick, PSA10 slabs, Trout, Skenes, De La Cruz etc. she went there with over $900 dollars in comped confirmed sale prices the day she walked into that shop, and she came home with a little over $300. I understand shops have to make money but overhead on a quick moving PSA 10 top player for what she was paid, is in the simplest of terms, “Highway Robbery”. Made my blood boil when she came home and told me the amount she was paid. Those were top end PSA10 cards of cards that no doubt will move quickly. I’ll not give them a penny of business moving forward let alone ever walk back in that store to sell a single card. Go to Mavericks and there you’ll at least be treated fairly for cards you’re looking to sell.

My fiance came in yesterday 6/7/26 to see about a possibility of selling come cards. He has never felt so uncomfortable or out of place in his life. The staff working was not welcoming at all. Unless you are a regular here you are not welcomed as I’ve had the same experience when I brought my 7 yr old son in last year to purchase some Pokémon cards. I wasn’t even greeted when we walked in and they were only focused on all the boys opening boxes at the counter. This staff needs retrained on customer service especially with being a small business!

We enjoy our experience here every time. My son will spend a couple hours a visit going through the quarter bins, particularly the Formula 1 cards. We look forward to going…. what seems to be every weekend.

No love for NASCAR. They had plenty of 2026 hobby boxes. None now. Kid went in the back to check came out 7 seconds later and said “we’re out” lol ok dude. They did have 2025 Prizim blasters but no 2026 Donruss hobby. Found something at GameStop.

GET YOUR CARDS HERE. PLEASE. Great service and helped to work a deal for a nice lot before the season. Really cool collection of auto jerseys I have to say. cozy shop with cool artwork and tvs to watch sports and open cards with their vast selection. Really enjoyed this store a lot though wish they had a little better selection of singles, can’t complain! 10/10