Where2PlayTCG
StoresStatesTCGs
Suggest a store

Where2PlayTCG

Where2PlayTCG is an independent directory of game stores and TCG communities. We're continually expanding our coverage to help players find places to buy, play, and connect.

All storesStatesTCGsSuggest a storeAll countries
BlogContactPrivacyTerms & ConditionsCookies

© 2026 Where2PlayTCG. Hours and event details may vary — confirm with each store before you go.

HomeStoresOrange CountyMiddletownGameStop - 7791 - Walkill Plaza
GameStop - 7791 - Walkill Plaza, a TCG store in Middletown

Photo via Google Maps

GameStop - 7791 - Walkill Plaza

400 Route 211 E, 10940 Middletown, New York

3.9(244 reviews on Google)
Magic: The Gathering

La gente dice que esta tienda está limpia y organizada, y ofrece una variedad de productos como tarjetas de béisbol y de Pokémon. Destacan también al personal, que es amable y servicial, y que brinda un servicio e información excelentes. Otras personas dicen que la tienda puede estar cerrada inesperadamente.

Summary by Gemini based on Google reviews. Report content

(845) 341-1220 Website View on Google Maps

Tuesday: 12 PM–8 PM

Open now
View full schedule
  • Monday: 12 PM–8 PM
  • Tuesday: 12 PM–8 PM
  • Wednesday: 12 PM–8 PM
  • Thursday: 12 PM–8 PM
  • Friday: 11 AM–9 PM
  • Saturday: 11 AM–9 PM
  • Sunday: 12 PM–8 PM
Accepts cards Wheelchair accessible

Google Reviews

Frenchelle Williams

2 months ago

I just wanted to buy some baseball cards, the cashier was talking to a customer so I waited when I realized that he was just talking in general not about a purchase I said excuse me he turned around and gave me a nasty look like I was bothering him. I dislike feeling like I’m out of place in a store. This was the first and last time for me!

Devin Kulbaba

4 months ago

Absolutely pathetic excuse of a store doesn’t matter when I come to this store who ever runs it is on their own time it must be nice to show up to work whenever you feel like it. On multiple occasions I have shown up when they are supposed to open and had to wait in excess of 15 minutes to an hour for someone to come open the store. Today 6/6/26 there was 10 people outside waiting for 45 minutes, good thing there’s a Best Buy 5 minutes down the street. GameStop is a thing of the past stores closing all over employees open the store when they feel like it. GameStop should just give up surrender and throw in the towel move to online only if you can’t get employees to open the store on time.!!!!!!!!!!

Maria Ramos

4 months ago

Employee was super nice and very helpful. Store was very clean and organized. It was so nice to actually see a game stop busy! I went in to buy some baseball cards.

Michael Grain

6 months ago

Do not buy from this store, Nick is disrespectful and unhelpful. I preordered an item that was damaged and defective. Nick knew about the defective item and still handed it to me and said he couldn’t issue a refund. This is unacceptable, it misrepresents the condition promise, he barely gets any customers now so he is willing to scam everyone out of their money. I rather drive 30 miles to another store than to ever buy from this store again. Unbelievable! YOU SHOULD BE FIRED!

Ruben T.

7 months ago

Went to this store and had a sign that it was closed and won't be back a certain time. SmH. Game stop should just close down totally. Totally unreliable and scam you by low balling selling back games. I knew there was a reason I haven't been back to these stores.

Reviews pulled from Google

Visited this store? Leave your review on Google