American Historic Coins, Cards & Collectibles

The edited response from the scalper owner says all it needs to to be honest but... BUYER BEWARE. I bought several things and opened all of it in my car in front of this business, bet you don’t have cameras out there tho right? 🤡 I flipped over the pack in question to open it the foil had clearly been separated and resealed. I have opened so many packs and this has never happened to me. I have nothing to gain in saying this, but you have lots to gain from denying responsibility, opening and resealing packs and selling them at double retail. They sold me a resealed phantasmal flames pack. The guy tried to say it was a production error, never heard of the packs coming unsealed and getting resealed on the production line before. He exchanged the pack for one that was not so obviously tampered with, did not offer a refund. I don’t really trust anything I purchased now unfortunately it’s basically just a loss. I will not be returning and I would highly caution anyone who goes here to inspect your packs before you leave the premises. Such a shame stuff like this happens, really sucks all the fun away from a hobby that should be enjoyed by all.

Hands down one of the best places ive received coins from. They are open to all questions and want you to love the coin you're buying as much as they do before it's sold. Can only write the one review, but I'd do it 10x over if I could. 5 stars 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟 🌟

American Historic is the absolute best place for coins, bullion, collectibles, anything your heart desires! Always a fair price when buying and selling. The staff is fantastic and I can't sing their praises enough! 100/10 highly recommend!

Decided to travel all the way from Iowa to come visit these guys because of how awesome they are in their online presence. Let’s give an open and honest review. Some of the most helpful and honest people in the coin and bullion space. Watched them sit down with several customers who wanted to invest heavily into precious metals and they received a consultation that was so thorough and helpful and allowed them to make good wise decisions on their investment. They have people there that cover the entire gambit of coins, bullion, and all things collectible. We currently live in a time where you do not get that kind of customer service and everybody is in it for the dollar but with these guys I was genuinely shocked to see how much time and effort they spent to give any and all information to the buyers so they could make the best decision for them financially and situationally. Some of the most top-notch product people in service I have witnessed in a very long time. Period to anybody local or from far away I couldn’t recommend these guys more highly.

Some of the guys are nice. None of them know the current price on the coins or bullion they are selling, takes 5 minutes to find out a single price only to hear they are wildly overpriced. Way higher prices than any of the other coin shops around MA, RI and NH.