5 Star Cards / Sellers Sportscards & Breaks LLC is my GTS Account Name

Always a great experience, clean and organized shop and great presence on eBay. They do a lot of both Pokémon and sports cards. Employees are friendly and owner is fun to talk with.

Overall decent shop, but I’d rather go to other. It is a nice small shop in downtown, a good place to stop if you are already down there, but their selection isn’t the best. A lot of the most popular recent products aren’t there, and some of the stuff other shops have is just missing. Their 25 cent bins are just a waste of time to me. Almost all of the cards in them are just base chrome of random people or maybe a couple parallels. The staff is nice, the location is good, I just don’t think that they are up there with other shops.

Fantastic experience. Matt took the time to carefully inspect a card I brought in that I had purchased from someone else months ago, explained what he was seeing, and gave me honest feedback without any pressure. Extremely knowledgeable, professional, and genuinely helpful. He went above and beyond for me, and I really appreciated the kindness and generosity. Highly recommended, and will absolutely be returning!

This shop really is 5 star! A true family run business that cares about its customers! We will be lifelong customers after they went above and beyond for our kids! They had a blast getting and opening their Pokemon cards and the owners even gave them fresh sleeves for their cards! Very fair prices that even allowed Dad some nostalgia fun! Thanks again and see you soon!

I had a great experience purchasing PSA-graded cards from 5 Star Cards of Wisconsin. The entire process was smooth from start to finish. The cards arrived exactly as described, securely packaged, and in excellent condition. It’s clear they take care in handling collectible items, which is really important when you’re buying graded cards. Communication was solid and shipping was quick. You can tell they know the hobby and care about their customers. I’d definitely recommend 5 Star Cards of Wisconsin to anyone looking to buy PSA slabs or other collectibles. I’ll definitely be buying from them again in the future.