SPORTS CARD ALLEY

Favorite place to play magic in town! Always a great selection of sealed, owners and staff and friendly, players are cool, and singles are fairly priced and well organized. Highly recommend checking out their events, competitive but still fun and beginner friendly :)

Best spot on the mid island for Magic, sealed or singles. Limited events hosted for every new set and popular commander nights. Helpful staff and a friendly atmosphere makes it easy to start playing if you’re new to Magic or new to town.

I’m a little annoyed I have to do this because I loved the shop and was a frequent customer when Bill ran it … but I’m out nearly $4000 and two cases because of this shop … it started last March (2025) when I wanted to buy 3 cases from Bill for some 2022-23 UD Series 2 , 2022-23 UD extended series and a case of 2022-23 OPC platinum. At the time I was able to buy the 2022-23 UD series 2 because Bill had a case in store but the other two he wasn’t able to get at that moment he told me if I wanted to have them ordered in he could as long as I paid for them so I gave him $1200 for the extended and $2700 for the platinum ($3900 cash) I always dealt with bill using cash and never had any issues with receipts … well the cases never arrived it’s to my understanding that Bill had some serious issues with his health so I waiting patiently I tried to go into the store last year and had little luck getting a proper answer out of the guys that worked there at the time they just told me “Bill will be getting out of the hospital come back and talk to him when he’s here” well unfortunately Bill has since passed away and now I’m out my money and the boxes of my cards and the issue doesn’t seem like it’s going to be fixed so it’s save to say Sport card alley is definitely on my black list now which sucks because this was my go to store. I hope you reach out and try to make this right with me but I doubt it.

Shop has gotten a lot nicer and tidy compared to years before…good selection for hockey. Just pulled a Schaefer from a hobby box bought from them as well!

There's a really nice card store the owners are friendly they even gave us a free welcome deck to try magic the gathering they have like Commander tournaments on Thursdays and Sunday I think it starts at like noon you can call their phone number to get the schedule they pick up right away there's plenty of comfortable chairs for seating.